A comparative study of curriculum, spaces and new educational technologies in architectural education system of the top five universities of the world

Maneshi, M.; Tahaei, S.  A.; Mirshahzadeh, Sh.

doi:10.22061/tej.2023.9587.2864

Document Type : Review Paper

Authors

Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22061/tej.2023.9587.2864

Abstract

Background and Objectives: There is a large gap between education in architecture schools in Iran and modern educational methods in advanced industrial countries. Iran educational methods are still the same as in the past, which unfortunately have not kept pace with the changes of the new era, and this can be one of the reasons for the ineffectiveness of architectural education in Iran. The architecture schools need to be changed due to the changes in the educational system and the increasing needs of students to communication and modern technologies. In other words, the pervasiveness of new technologies has affected the educational system and the educational environment must continuously adapt to the improvements and developments of today's world. The most important goal of the educational system is to educate capable and competent individuals and produce extensive knowledge to meet the changing needs of the modern world for life and a growing society. In fact, the educational system must constantly strive to respond to the educational innovations and evolutions and prepare students for a rapidly changing world. The need for change, modernizing and updating the educational spaces is important in parallel with the new educational flow in architecture and urban planning faculties. This research comparatively examined the curriculum, spaces and new educational technologies in the architecture education system in selected universities of the world. The purpose of the research was to identify solutions for reforming the university architecture education system in Iran.
Methods: The present study was descriptive, analytical and applied. Content analysis was based on an inductive approach. The research sample was purposefully selected from among the leading architectural schools in the world, which were selected by valid evaluations. The research method was comparative with qualitative approach and based on the stages of George Bereday's comparative Method in education: Description, Interpretation, Juxtaposition and Comparison. The data and documents were collected from library studies, books and articles, web-based information that were categorized and analyzed in tables and charts format and the common qualitative characteristics of the top schools of architecture in the world were determined.
Findings: Analyses performed on the samples showed that the use of new educational technologies would play a central role in the curriculum of the educational system and was effective in improving the level of education and learning of students. Also, some of the innovations of this field were recognized in the top universities of the world. Among the most important of these innovations were frequent revisions of the curriculum, working in workshop environments with advanced equipment, holding educational trips, preparing students for the job market, holding lectures and exhibitions with the presence of contemporary architects, working in work environments with real employers and prominent architectural offices.
Conclusion: A comparison of the strategies of MIT, Harvard, Rice, Sci-Arc and Cooper Union universities showed that MIT and Harvard offer the most flexible curriculum among the universities, while using a suitable educational environment with advanced and up-to-date architectural equipment and facilities. Rice University increases the creativity of students with the possibility of apprenticeship in the offices of prominent architects and holding classes and courses about current and future architectural issues and challenges. With the approach of creating flexibility and dynamism in the teaching method, Sci-Arc School emphasizes the innovative innovations and creative solutions in architectural design, holding lectures and exhibitions with the presence of world-renowned professors and architects, and emphasizing the interaction between professors and students. Cooper Union School, in addition to providing a suitable educational environment, focuses on the sociability of gathering spaces and increasing social interactions between the general public, students and professors. As a result, the university architecture curriculum must be in line with new developments in the education process. Technology and its advanced tools and critical thinking are considered as essential and vital factors for success in architecture education. It is necessary to take a step towards improving the quality of architecture education by using technologies and making all necessary changes to revise and reorganize the educational system.

Keywords

20.1001.1.20080441.1402.17.4.15.0

Main Subjects

Technology-based learning environments

COPYRIGHTS
©2023 The author(s). This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, as long as the original authors and source are cited. No permission is required from the authors or the publishers.

References

[1] Aesaret, K., Vanderlinde, R., Tondeur, J., & Braak, J. V . The content of educational technology curricula: a cross-curricular state of the art, Education Tech Research Dev . 2013 ,(61):131–151.

[2] Kamelnia. Hamed. Grammar of designing learning environments .2009. Persian.

[3] Hamidi, F., Ghorbandordinejad, F., Rezaee, M., & Jafari, M. A Comparison of the Use of Educational Technology in the Developed/Developing Countries, Procedia Computer Science. 2011, (3): 374–377.

[4] Fallah, Robbah. Heydari, Shaban. Yahya zadeh, Suleiman. Evaluation of smart and traditional schools in terms of efficiency in creating self-regulating learners in line with the transformation of the country's fifth development plan system. Journal of Educational planning studies, 2015, (8): 35-62. Persian.

[5] Harrison, C , Cavendish, S, Comber, C, Fisher, T, Harrison, A , Haw, K, et al. ImpaCT2: The impact of information and communication technologies on pupil learning and attainment. ICT in Schools Research and Evaluation. 2002. Series 7.

[6] Baylor, A.L. & Ritchie, D. What factors facilitate teacher skill, teacher morale, and perceived student learning in technology-using classrooms? Computers & Education. 2002, 39(4), 395-414.

[7] Gorji Mahalabani Y. [Today’s Architecture Education and Future Concerns]. Technology of Education Journal. 2010, 4(3): 223-234. Persian.

[8] Azizi, Shadi. Flexible system architecture necessary training toward to slove vernacular and global challenges of sustainability. Hoviate Shahr. 2010. 7, 43-52. Persian.

[9] Alalhesabi M. Norouzian Maleki S. [Experience of Design Education in Schools of Architecture]. Technology of Education Journal. 2009; 3(4); 323-336. Persian.

[10] Sattari, S., Mohammadi, P. Survey of Relation between Application of Information Technology and High School Academic Achievement. Information and Communication Technology in Educational Sciences, 2011; 1(4): 81-96. Persian.

[11] Nasiri, Mohammad Hamzah. Comparing the educational progress of students trained through Picture with other students in East Azarbaijan province. Curriculum Planning Research Institute and Educational innovations. 1999. Persian.

[12] Khezerlou, Hamed. Examining the effective factors in the tendency of elementary teachers to use media Training in the teaching and learning process of teachers in Urmia. Planning Research Institute Curriculum and educational innovations. 2000. Persian.

[13] Yazdchi. Safora. Investigating the effect of video tapes on students' progress in mathematics. Guide and summary of the articles of the 6th National Mathematics Conference. 2010.Persian.

[14] Vahid Rad, Zakie. Examining the characteristics of the content of university courses according to the needs of today's society. Abstracts of the articles of the 9th annual conference of the Iranian Curriculum Studies Association. Tabriz: Tabriz University. 2018. Persian.

[15] Vahidi. Tahir. Research on the factors of discontinuity in the theoretical and practical education of the basic courses of architecture. (A case study is Shahid Beheshti University). The thesis of M.A. 2004. Persian.

[16] Afzalnia, Mohammadreza. Design and familiarization with material centers and learning resources. SAMT Publications. 2008. Tehran. Persian.

[17] Beiramipour, A., Bakhtiar Nasrabadi, H., Hashemi, S. H. Post modernism and modification in curriculum. New Educational Approaches, 2010; 5(1): 31-64. Persian.

[18] Salisbili, Nader et al. Draft document and publication on reforms in education and upbringing in Iran. Tehran: Research Institute of Education and Training .2003. Persian.

[19] Ahdian, Mohammad an introduction to educational technology. Payam Noor University. Tehran. 1994. Persian.

[20] Fardanesh, Hashem. Theoretical foundations of educational technology. Tehran. 2009. Persian.

[21] Lowerison, G., Sclater, J., Schmid, R. F., & Abrami, P. Student perceived effectiveness of computer technology use in post-secondary classrooms. Computers & Education. 2006, 47(4), 465–489.

[22] kulik, J. A. “Meta-analysis Study of Findings on Computer-based Instruction”. Technology Assessment in Education and Training. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. 1994.

[23] Roblyer, M. "Intergrating Educational Technology into Teaching", (3rd ed) Upper Saddle River, Nj: Merrill Prentice Hall. 2003.

[24] Zolfaghar, Mohsen. Reviewing and analyzing the teaching quality of humanities faculty members. M.A. Thesis. 1996. Persian.

[25] Arisian, Nasrin. The new role of teachers in education due to the development of information technology. Proceedings of the first conference on education. 2006, Persian.

[26] Mohammadi, Mahdi. Jafari, Sakineh. The relationship between organizational characteristics, knowledge, skills and the attitude of high school teachers with their sense of self-confidence in using technology education, Journal of Education and Learning Studies. 2012, 4 (1): 105-136. Persian.

[27] Jariani, Abulqasem. The impact of information and communication technology on curriculum planning. Office of planning and authoring technical and professional education , vocational training . 2010 , Persian .

[28] Sedaghati, Abbas, Hojat, Essa. Comparing the success rate of architecture training courses after the revolution. Journal of Architectural Thought, 2019, 4 (7): 44-57. Persian.

[29] Attaran, M. Globalization, information technology and education. Tehran: Aftab-e Mehr.2002, Persian.

[30] Gholamalizadeh.Hamzeh, Mokhberi Naghmeh. Effective Features of the Physical Environment for the Growth Potential Talents of Architecture Students. Journal of Armanshahr Architecture & Urban Development. 2015 ,7 (13): 81-91. Persian.

[31] Heydari Ali Akbar, Yazdanfar Seid Abbas, Behdadfar Nazgol. (2014). Providing a Model to Explain the Meaning of Place in Educational Environments Case Study: Comparison of Meaning of Place in the School of Architecture and Non-Architectural. Journal of Iranian Architectuire & Urbanism. 2014, 4 (1) :49-62. Persian.

[32] Mozaeidi, Mohammad, Abedkish, Sadrullah, Khoshbakht, Fariba, karimi, mohammad hassan. Analyzing the position of critical thinking in Iran's upper education documents in terms of the application of critical thinking components. Journal of Islam and educational research. 2020, 23: 23-40. Persian.

[33] https://www.mit.edu/

[34] https://www.gsd.harvard.edu/architecture/

[35] https://arch.rice.edu/school/facilities

[36] https://www.sciarc.edu/

[37] https://cooper.edu/architecture/student-work/end-year-exhibitions

[38] Aghazadeh. Ahmed. (2014). Comparative education. Tehran. Persian.

[39] https://www.archdaily.com/625569/qs-ranks-the-top-100-universities-in-the-world-for-architecture/

[40] http://www.elaine.com/portfolio_page/mit-school-of-architecture-library/

[41] https://www.mds-bos.com/mit-building-6120-lecture-hall

[42] https://www.flickr.com/photos/cpsphotolibrary/7204370174

[43] https://www.archdaily.com/tag/mit

[44] https://www.alamy.com/the-harvard-graduate-school-of-design